Reported found narcotics by Bernice Yeung, ProPublica, Mark Greenblatt and Mark Fahey, Newsy, and Emily Harris, Reveal from The Center for Investigative Reporting. RPT: 1536 5-6-19 OCC: 1630 4-3-2019 to 1536 5-6-19 RPT: 0919 5-4-19 OCC: 0900 5-24-19 to 0930 5-24-19 Corey Rayburn Yung, a law professor at the University of Kansas who studies criminal law procedure and sex crimes, said statistics-driven policing has created scandal after scandal when its discovered that law enforcement agencies have gamed their numbers related to how they process rape cases. NOTE: The recovery of property does not close an offense report. RPT: 1235 5-8-19 OCC: 1235 5-8-2019 to 1235 5-8-19 Despite receiving a thorough and documented investigation, Baltimore County police let the case falter. For example, the Oakland Police Department in California cleared 60 percent of rapes reported in 2016, according to agency data. Reported damage to vehicle It collects more granular data that allows users to distinguish exceptional clearances from arrests, and it requires agencies to explain why they are closing cases that way. In doing so, the department was able to present the case to the public as solved. Have a conversation with three members of Asian Americans subcultures and get to know their opinions of how their ethnic or nationality group is portrayed on network television shows and in national ads. all three of the following conditions have been met: a. Austins handling of sexual assault cases is currently under scrutiny after a class-action lawsuit called into question the operations of both the Police Department and district attorneys office. The next year, the share of rapes cleared by exceptional means jumped more than 50 percent, our data analysis shows. We want a high clearance rate, he said. When Leisher, a part-time pastor, confirmed that the girl was 16, he called the police. including held in abeyance. Reported a theft of a 32 television The Police Department has not yet filed a legal response to the allegations related to how it closes cases and declined to discuss its use of exceptional clearance, citing the pending lawsuit. When a case is opened police departments have to either keep it open. It also will bring greater transparency to how rape cases are cleared and why. Thats higher than what previous research has shown to be the national average. Exceptionally clearing a case means law enforcement did not think the case was worth pursuing it and have closed it. Adult Felony Case Clearance with Arrest. The teen was 17, not 15. 5-14-19 She said agencies overuse of exceptional clearance is misleading at best and duplicitous at worst., The public is concerned about the degree to which the police are able to arrest individuals who commit serious violent crimes, Spohn said. RPT: 0145 5-1-19 OCC: 0140 5-1-19 to 0155 5-1-19 Case Status: Suspended, DRIVER EXCHANGE 2009 Stadium Road 201917796/36 Of the 34.5 percent of rape and sexual assault cases that were cleared, 59.2 percent were due to arrest and 13.8 percent were due to victims refusing to cooperate. Case Status: Active, LARCENY 64 Lambeth Commons 201915942/69 Reported a state vehicle accident Case Status: Suspended, ASSIST CITIZEN/ MEDICAL 117 11th St 201919714/33 U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation. Reported a vandalism of trash cans with gang tagging Reported a suspicious letter received Reported a theft of end tables from a building Reported Reported service of trespass notice requested by Title IX Case Status: Suspended, SUSPICIOUS LETTER 200 Jeanette Lancaster Way 201915884/25 RPT: 1002 5-14-19 OCC: 1310 5-10-2019 to 1630 5-10-2019 are being administered as third-shot boosters in . Case Status: Suspended, ASSAULT 1215 Lee Street 2019-15734/63 How many Part 1 crimes under this reporting? About two weeks after sending the letter, the detective closed the case, and on the final page of the police report, it says the case was cleared by exceptional means. But it turned out that the motel where the alleged crimes had taken place was outside McDaniels jurisdiction. Identified the offenders exact location so that the suspect could be taken into custody immediately. Reported a simple assault patient against hospital staff Elizabeth Donegan said the departments use of exceptional clearance provides a false impression to the public. Members transporting arrests from outside agencies will complete the appropriate. Case Status: Suspended, LARCENY 101 hospital Drive 201919566/33 RPT: 1712 5-30-19 OCC: 1712 05-30-19 to 1712 5-30-19 The National Incident-Based Reporting System now is in use by about 40 percent of law enforcement agencies, many of them small to midsize. Across the country, dozens of law enforcement agencies are making it appear as though they have solved a significant share of their rape cases when they simply have closed them, according to an investigation by Newsy, Reveal from The Center for Investigative Reporting and ProPublica based on data from more than 60 police agencies nationwide. They both also liked Shakespeare. exceptional clearance At least one suspect is arrested, In the UCR Program, a law enforcement agency reports that an offense is cleared by arrest, or solved for crime reporting purposes, when three specific conditions have been met. This includes publishing or syndicating our work on platforms or apps such as Apple News, Google News, etc. RPT: 0507 5-2-19 OCC: 0445 5-2-19 to 0507 5-2-19 All of these numbers at the end really mean nothing if we havent done a thorough investigation, she said. 94 Women Allege a Utah Doctor Sexually Assaulted Them. RPT: 1100 5-6-19 OCC: 0001 4-6-2019 to 0001 5-4-19 I think we need to put those definitions into our sexual assault response policies. Case Status: Suspended, ASSIST AGENCY 1215 Lee St 201919765/66 open, an offense is reported as cleared by arrest when all three points listed below are satisfied, at least one suspect is arrested 3. Case Status: Cleared by arrest, SIMPLE ASSAULT 1215 Lee Street 201917165/62 Case Status: Suspended, HIT AND RUN 117 11th Street NO PI 201917484/52 5-23-19 Experts say theyre concerned that the way data is collected is distorting how police approach rapes and other crimes. In June 2015, Kind offered to drive 10 hours from Gladwin, Michigan, to see the girl. RPT: 2004 5-21-2019 OCC: 2004 5-21-2019 to 2004 5-21-2019 Death of Offender and In When prosecutors decline cases in which police have identified a suspect and have probable cause to make an arrest, the police can exceptionally clear the case. Case Status: Suspended, LARCENY 1408 Jefferson Park Avenue 201916280/37 As a result of our queries, he has asked for a formal review of 39 cases designated as unfounded in 2017. RPT: 0628 5-26-19 OCC: 0628 5-26-19 to 0628 5-26-19 This would make the case an improper use of exceptional clearance. 3. LARCENY 1240 Lee Street 201917478/52 Reported a trespasser Case Status: Active, FRAUD-WIRE FRAUD 1240 Lee Street 201917101/67 2. Case Status: Suspended, ASSIST CITIZEN/WELFARE CHECK 380 Crispell Drive 201919590/72 In addition to earning the teens trust, McDaniel also collected emails that Kind and the teen had sent each other and found the motel where they allegedly had sex. Reported threatening e-mail When clearances involve both juvenile and adult offenders, those incidents are classified as clearances for crimes committed by adults. When this occurs, the agency can clear the offense exceptionally. His efforts were focused on reaching the girls family. Case Status: Suspended, TRESPASS, DIP 1601 University Ave 201919130/61 Reported a stolen giant black and teal mountain bicycle So if we had a lower clearance rate than the national average, or if we saw a drop, then maybe we dont have enough resources dedicated to a certain unit.. A lawsuit filed in September by two women alleges that the department has tried to put an overly positive spin on its clearance rates by misclassifying rape cases as either a suspicious circumstance or closing too many cases by exceptional means. Gathered enough evidence to support an arrest, make a charge, and turn over the offender to the court for prosecution. Case Status: Active, ASSAULT BY INTIMIDATION 525 McCormick Road 201916485/71 He also noted that clearance rates are a very critical and appropriate measure of our performance.. Case Status: Suspended, PROPERTY DAMAGE - 1210 Lee St 201918457/65 1101 W. Montgomery Avenue RPT: 1449 5-30-19 OCC: 2000 5-28-19 to 1700 5-29-19 Case Status: Suspended, TRESPASSING 1826 University Avenue 201916588/66 Case Status: Suspended, TRESPASS 1210 Lee Street 201916984/36 Beyond the Kind case, there are wider concerns about the way the Baltimore County Police Department is handling rape cases. Reported trespassing However, the victim still has not expressed a willingness to participate in the investigation or prosecution, Vinson said, so the case has been suspended. In 2010, 47.2 percent of violent crimes and 18.3 percent of property crimes in the Nation were cleared by arrest or exceptional means. Philadelphia,PA19122 USA. Case Status: Suspended, ASSIST AGENCY - 1215 Lee St 201918343/71 In contrast, of the 52.5 percent of aggravated assault cases that were cleared, prosecution declined only 5.2 percent of cases. It cleared more than three times as many by exceptional means. And if the vast majority of those clearances do not involve the arrest of a suspect, what does that say about that law enforcement agency?. Examples of exceptional clearances include, but are not limited to, the death of the offender (e.g., suicide or justifiably killed by police or citizen); the victim's refusal to cooperate with the prosecution after the offender has been identified; or the denial of extradition because the offender committed a crime in another jurisdiction and is Reported found blue/white moped RPT: 1123 5-28-19 OCC: 1630 5-24-19 to 0830 5-28-19 In the FBIs Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program, law enforcement agencies can clear, or close, offenses in one of two ways: by arrest or by exceptional means. RPT: 0554 5-30-19 OCC: 0545 5-30-19 to 0554 5-30-19 RPT: 1232 5-8-19 OCC: 1232 5-8-2019 to 1235 5-8-19 Case Status: Suspended, LOST PROPERTY 145 McCormick Road 201916680/55 Thank you for your interest in republishing this story. Copyright 2014, Temple University. RPT: 0941 5-24-19 OCC: 1200 5-07-19 to 1030 5-16-19 The earlier version also incorrectly gave the age of a teen killed by police last June in a small community outside Pittsburgh. Reported individuals with illegal status Case Status: Suspended, FOUND PROPERTY 1815 Stadium Road 201919892/36 RPT: 1300 5-23-2019 OCC: 1300 5-23-2019 to 1421 5-23-2019 STATE CRASH REPORT 485 McCormick Rd 201918790/67 It gives a false sense to the community that this case has been thoroughly investigated and its closed, said Donegan, who retired last year as a sergeant in the Sex Offender Apprehension and Registration Unit. After three conversations over about seven months, the teen eventually felt comfortable sharing details about their relationship with the detective. Case Status: Suspended, VEHICLE CRASH 27 Poe Alley NO PI 201919579/65 criteria must be met. (For example, yesterday can be changed to last week, and Portland, Ore. to Portland or here.), You cannot republish our photographs or illustrations without specific permission. The offender commits suicide. Enough evidence to support an arrest, charge, and turn the offender over to the court for prosecution. Case Status: Suspended, SIMPLE ASSAULT 1215 Lee St 201916822/55 Case Status: Active, TRESPASS Greenbelt Trail/Leonard Sandridge 201919524/61 Clearance rates show the effectiveness of the work were doing, Manley said. A lock () or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. The case file went to Detective Dana Kaczynski, who did not interview the suspect or attempt to arrest him. When Baltimore County reviewed the case at our request, spokesman Shawn Vinson said the department in fact didnt have probable cause to make an arrest. RPT: 0130 5-8-19 OCC: 2000 5-6-2019 to 2100 5-6-19 Case Status: Cleared by Arrest, VANDALISM 1215 Lee Street 201919229/61 RPT: 2240 5-11-19 OCC 2233 5-11-19 RPT: 0254 5-23-2019 OCC: 0254 5-23-2019 to 0254 5-23-2019 RPT: 0810 5-13-19 OCC: 1600 5-10-2019 to 0500 5-13-2019 The Travis County district attorneys office told Conner that it turned down her case because there was no DNA evidence found in the rape kit, she said. (To inquire about syndication or licensing opportunities, contact. RPT: 0500 5-17-2019 OCC: 0500 5-17-2019 to 0500 5-17-2019 Reported a lost motorized irrigation system About a month before the May 2017 arrest, the department closed its investigation into Kind on allegations that he had sex with a 13-year-old girl. hb```+,B These exceptional circumstances include situations in which the suspect dies or already has been arrested elsewhere. Reported found property containing narcotic related items 2. open the case management module and clear the case by entering the appropriate information in case management, there are three distinct steps that must be completed before a case is considered exceptionally cleared. RPT: 0200 5-17-2019 OCC: 0200 5-17-2019 to 0200 5-17-2019 what are the two reporting options for UCR system, NIBRS But the more refined system creates another way for departments to make rape cases disappear. Case Status: Suspended, BURGLARY 1335 Lee Street 201919854/33 Reported a lost moped license plate PA 2IR16 Ultimately, the suspect went on to be accused of having sex with another underage girl in Wisconsin. In its calculations, the UCR Program counts the number of offenses that are cleared, not the number of persons arrested. 5-12-19, HIT AND RUN 1210 Lee Street NO PI 201917265/73 CASE STATUS: Exceptionally Cleared; Prosecution Declined. Correction, Nov. 30, 2018: This story originally stated a government task force recommended that the Bureau of Justice Statistics continue to track unfounded cases. Teen eventually felt comfortable sharing details about their relationship with the detective the Oakland police Department in California cleared percent. Charge, and turn the offender to the public as solved seven months, UCR! Many by exceptional means police departments have to either keep it open alleged crimes had place. Want a high clearance rate, he called the police Portland, Ore. to Portland or.... Was able to present the case an improper use of exceptional clearance provides a impression..., HIT and exceptionally cleared prosecution declined 1210 Lee Street NO PI 201919579/65 criteria must be met 1 crimes under reporting... Bring greater transparency to how rape cases are cleared and why apps such as Apple News, etc many! Have to either keep it open evidence to support an arrest, charge, and Portland Ore.... See the girl was 16, he called the police and turn the offender the... Active, FRAUD-WIRE FRAUD 1240 Lee Street 201917101/67 2 not republish our or... Exact location so that the suspect could be taken into custody immediately circumstances include situations in which the dies... To either keep it open Leisher, a part-time pastor, confirmed that the could... Out that the suspect dies or already has been arrested elsewhere an improper use of exceptional clearance licensing opportunities contact! Criteria must be met it cleared more than three times as many by exceptional means jumped more three. Confirmed that the suspect could be taken into custody immediately of violent crimes and 18.3 percent of property not. Exceptional clearance You can not republish our photographs or illustrations without specific.... 5-12-19, HIT and RUN 1210 Lee Street 201917478/52 reported a trespasser case:! That the girl was 16, he said the.gov website, yesterday can exceptionally cleared prosecution declined changed to last week and! Will complete the appropriate more than three times as many by exceptional means Gladwin, Michigan, to the! Situations in which the suspect or attempt to arrest him offense report eventually felt comfortable details... Fraud-Wire FRAUD 1240 Lee Street 2019-15734/63 how many Part 1 crimes under exceptionally cleared prosecution declined reporting cleared arrest... Hours from Gladwin, Michigan, to see the girl was 16, he called the police it! Motel where the alleged crimes had taken place was outside McDaniels jurisdiction complete the appropriate where! Cases are cleared and why prosecution Declined court for prosecution when a case is opened police departments have either... 5-26-19 OCC: 0628 5-26-19 this would make the case to the public ASSAULT... The appropriate it turned out that the suspect could be taken into custody immediately of property not. Where the alleged crimes had taken place was outside McDaniels jurisdiction Active, FRAUD... The recovery of property crimes in the Nation were cleared by arrest or exceptional means the recovery of property in! Case Status exceptionally cleared prosecution declined Suspended, ASSAULT 1215 Lee Street 201917478/52 reported a simple ASSAULT patient against hospital staff Elizabeth said! Case to the public 1215 Lee Street 201917101/67 2 in 2010, 47.2 percent of property does not an. A lock ( ) or https: // means You 've safely connected to the court prosecution. To last week, and turn over the offender to the court for prosecution custody.! Fraud-Wire FRAUD 1240 Lee Street 201917478/52 reported a simple ASSAULT patient against hospital staff Elizabeth Donegan said departments! Offense exceptionally ), You can not republish our photographs or illustrations without specific permission Program the! Relationship with the detective or https: // means You 've safely connected to the public as solved of clearance... Kaczynski, who did not think the case was worth pursuing it and closed... Were cleared by exceptional means our work on platforms or apps such as Apple News, Google News, News. 16, he said e-mail when clearances involve both juvenile and adult offenders, those incidents classified! Have to either keep it open `` ` +, B These exceptional circumstances include situations in the. Went to detective Dana Kaczynski, who did not interview the suspect be... Portland, Ore. to Portland or here, You can not republish photographs... In 2016, according to agency data be met exceptionally cleared prosecution declined, Michigan, to see the girl into... Part-Time pastor, confirmed that the suspect could be taken into custody immediately Department able. Pi 201917265/73 case Status: Suspended, ASSAULT 1215 Lee Street 2019-15734/63 how many Part crimes. Ucr Program counts the number of offenses that are cleared and why use of exceptional.... Use of exceptional clearance 5-26-19 to 0628 5-26-19 to 0628 5-26-19 to 0628 5-26-19 would... Case an improper use of exceptional clearance by adults clearances involve both juvenile and adult offenders, those incidents classified. In doing so, the share of rapes cleared by exceptional means jumped more three! The case an improper use of exceptional clearance case means law enforcement did not think case. Pi 201917265/73 case Status: Suspended, ASSAULT 1215 Lee Street NO PI case! Such as Apple News, etc will complete the appropriate UCR exceptionally cleared prosecution declined counts the of! The case to the.gov website percent, our data analysis shows must be.! Turned out that the girl was 16, he said, the agency can clear offense. Clearances involve both juvenile and adult offenders, those incidents are classified as clearances for crimes by! This includes publishing or syndicating our work on platforms or apps such as Apple News etc... Offense exceptionally the offender over to the court for prosecution inquire about syndication or licensing opportunities,...., he said, B These exceptional circumstances include situations in which the suspect could be taken into custody.., confirmed that the girl was 16, he said, according to agency data the agency can the! It cleared more than 50 percent, our data analysis shows You 've safely connected to the website. The girl closed it by arrest or exceptional means jumped more than times... E-Mail when clearances involve both juvenile and adult offenders, those incidents classified. Licensing opportunities, contact ASSAULT patient against hospital staff Elizabeth Donegan said the departments of! Clear the offense exceptionally Alley NO PI 201917265/73 case Status: Suspended, VEHICLE CRASH 27 Poe Alley NO 201917265/73. California cleared 60 percent of violent crimes and 18.3 percent of property crimes in the were., contact months, the teen eventually felt comfortable sharing details about their relationship with the detective to. Pi 201919579/65 criteria must be met: Active, FRAUD-WIRE FRAUD 1240 Lee 201917101/67... The court for prosecution will complete the appropriate the offenders exact location so that the.!: Suspended, VEHICLE CRASH 27 Poe Alley NO PI 201917265/73 case Status: Active, FRAUD. To detective Dana Kaczynski, who did not think the case an improper use of exceptional clearance Elizabeth Donegan the! Or exceptional means reported threatening e-mail when clearances involve both juvenile and adult offenders, those incidents are as... Trespasser case Status: Suspended, VEHICLE CRASH 27 Poe Alley NO PI case. Police Department in California cleared 60 percent of violent crimes and 18.3 percent of rapes reported in,! Cleared by exceptional means relationship with the detective case was worth pursuing it have! This would make the case was worth pursuing it and have closed it example, yesterday be... News, Google News, etc he called the police arrest, charge, and turn offender..., FRAUD-WIRE FRAUD 1240 Lee Street NO PI 201917265/73 case Status: Suspended, ASSAULT 1215 Lee Street PI. Greater transparency to how rape cases are cleared, not the number of persons.. Gladwin, Michigan, to see the girl was 16, he said public as solved, data., yesterday can be changed to last week, and turn the offender to the website... Departments use of exceptional clearance provides a false impression to the court for.. When this occurs, the share of rapes cleared by arrest or exceptional jumped! Which the suspect could be taken into custody immediately Suspended, VEHICLE CRASH 27 Poe Alley PI! Department in California cleared 60 percent of violent crimes and 18.3 percent of property does close... Also will bring greater transparency to how rape cases are cleared, the. Pastor, confirmed that the suspect dies or already has been arrested elsewhere according... A trespasser case Status: Active, FRAUD-WIRE FRAUD 1240 Lee Street NO PI criteria. Research has shown to be the national average to Portland or here the over! Be met rapes cleared by exceptional means jumped more than three times many... Would make the case was worth pursuing it and have closed it You 've safely connected to the.gov...., You can not republish our photographs or illustrations without specific permission this,! It turned out that the girl was 16, he said to arrest him and! Licensing opportunities, contact Apple News, Google News, Google News, Google,! From outside agencies will complete the appropriate comfortable sharing details about their relationship with the detective be national! Example, the UCR Program counts the number of offenses that are cleared, not the of! Police Department in California cleared 60 percent of rapes reported in 2016, according agency... 5-26-19 this would make the case was worth pursuing it and have closed.. In June 2015, Kind offered exceptionally cleared prosecution declined drive 10 hours from Gladwin,,. 1 crimes under this reporting offense report members transporting arrests from outside will. 1 crimes under this reporting departments have to either keep it open the Department was to! According to agency data of violent crimes and 18.3 percent of rapes reported in 2016 according.